Choices, Choices

Several years ago, well before I came across my now husband’s profile on a dating website (or more accurately before he came across mine), I remember my father sending me an article.
That in and of itself was not novel. My father loved us, but like so many immigrant fathers of a particular generation, his ways of showing it were not always conventional. Sending articles meant he was thinking of us.
This article was from the New York Times, entitled "When Doctors Become Patients." It painted the stark reality of being a patient diagnosed with cancer (head and neck cancer), while simultaneously being cognizant of both their raw experience as a patient while being able to see the other side from the physician's perspective, namely what metrics the clinical team were focused on. For my father, it was about sharing a physician's perspective on being the patient, something he felt was important for me at that time.
But this led to more interesting and sometimes morbid questions. What do doctors think of the treatments currently in use? What would they choose if faced with a similar, life-altering or life-limiting diagnosis?
In a 2014 study out of Stanford by Periyakoil and colleagues, it was noted that 88.3% of physician participants in their 2013 cohort--composed of a group of physicians from various sub-specialties--would choose to forego more intense treatments or remain full-code when faced with the end of life. There was some variability which in part was influenced by factors such as the sub-specialty of the physician, gender, and age.
I came across another blog piece some years later which shook my convictions about treatment choices while reshaping them. The piece was called "How doctors die. It's not like the rest of us, but it should be." I was in medical school at that point, and as a physician-in-training. I was learning about physiology and pharmacology, and all the other systemic -ologies with their respective treatment paradigms. But there was a rumbling in my darkest corners, one that probably started with the article my father sent all those years back, and soon that rumbling, that unsettled feeling, was brought to the light.
I knew then that if I was faced with a life-limiting diagnosis, at that point in time, I would not want to pursue anything aggressive. As my training went on, experience became a constant teacher. I would see patients through their side-effects and their decline. I would find myself part of the team tasked with trying to resuscitate a patient who had gone into cardiac arrest. I can still see their glassy vacant eyes, pupils cavernous voids, skin already drained of color. Their occupant had likely left the body and possibly the building while we all tried to find a rhythm to coax them to return.
"But you only see the worst," my husband would say after I went on about the risks of this or that, "your perspective can be skewed."
And perhaps he was right. Hospitals are where the sickest are seen for care. I couldn't speak to the experience of the folks walking down the street, maybe some of them were fresh from another chemotherapy infusion, port site sore but spirits high. Others still may be breathing well with their newly-transplanted lungs, or keeping pace with their loved ones as their newly-transplanted hearts thump-thumped in their chests. There were patients who were resuscitated successfully who I would never see again. I would never know what lives they would go on to have. All I knew was what I felt giving round after round of chest compressions in a situation where the story and numbers felt dire. I didn't want that, not for me, not for those I loved. That was my experience, and that was all I knew.
With each passing year, I've realized life has a way of changing the equations and making one reckon with what the next best steps really are.
Staring down The Bump on night one, hours after my husband's seizure, brought back all of those feelings. If it was me, I might have hung up my spurs and waited until my time was near, because my experiences as a physician seemed to point in that direction. I knew the numbers and I knew the treatments (standard of care anyways). I could feel the weight of those past experiences with patients with similar brain tumors, lying in their hospital beds, my experience shaped by theirs and vice versa. After my husband was settled into his hospital room, I had driven home. The sky was still dark, and for a time afterwards, everything felt a bit dimmer. My husband's future course seemed to blend with those of patients I had seen before. Again I was feeling the weight of numbers and statistics, of patients who by then could have been long gone, and again I found myself thinking about what I would do. In that moment, all I could do was despair.
The landscape now is very different from what it was all those years ago when I first read those articles. Never mind that research has continued to coax whispers of hope at every turn, even with a diagnosis like glioblastoma, there has been so much more that had changed. Back then, I only was accounting for myself. It really was just me, from my vantage point. Now, there was quite a bit more.
The man in the driver's seat is the same man who sat cross-legged next to me seven years ago when we had our wedding ceremony. I remember him squirming from discomfort while the priest intoned Sanskrit slokas and we smiled at each other. This is the same man who held me while I sobbed and struggled through death and loss of my own. There's the girl we're privileged to call our own, all mischief and snark, goading my husband into normalcy. There are so many people.
I'm in there too. But I am still two people, even now. The wife has settled into some semblance of a rhythm. She tries to be the wellspring of steadiness, of compassion, but every now and then it slows to a trickle, but not for long, and (so far) not exhausted. The neurologist continues to crunch the numbers and comb the literature, taking the objective and making sense of it. She considers the scans, the lab results, the discussions with his treatment team. But now, she considers the impact on this individual. How he is doing. How is he feeling? How are his labs and his symptoms affecting his ability to be present and continue with his day-to-day routine? To achieve his goals not only as a working professional but as a father, as a son, as a husband?
After all, it's not about treating lab values and scans. In this particular journey, every choice has implications for the man I love and the life we've built. As the patient, he has autonomy, the decision is ultimately his. For all the side-effects, I can see the other side, the man who claws his way out enough to run down the street with our daughter. So I'll be the bridge to help provide clarity, taking the dense jargon and mountain of lab values, filtering it through my experience as a physician, and combining it with his lived experience not only as a patient, but in all the roles he continues to play and will continue to play.
References
Periyakoil VS, Neri E, Fong A, Kraemer H (2014) Do Unto Others: Doctors’ Personal End-of-Life Resuscitation Preferences and Their Attitudes toward Advance Directives. PLoS ONE 9(5): e98246. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0098246
"How doctors die. It's not like the rest of us but it should be." by Ken Murray. Cancerworld (Archive). April 12, 2016.
"When Doctors Become Patients" by Eric D. Manheimer. The New York Times. September 2, 2011.
Comments